5-Day San Juan, Puerto Rico Itinerary for First-Time Visitors

Last Updated on June 3, 2025 by Erin Donahue

Planning a 5-day trip to San Juan? Here’s the perfect first-timer’s itinerary that covers where to stay, what to eat, and unique things to do, all from a personal experience. The Island of Enchantment is only about the size of Delaware and Rhode Island combined, offering a perfect blend of history, culture, and natural beauty.

This was my first time visiting, and while the stay was nice, the flights to and from on JetBlue were an absolute nightmare! Both inbound and outbound flights had six-hour delays, so my travel tip moving forward is always to book the earliest flight of the day. While it’s a miserable existence to wake up at 4 a.m. to get to the airport, those flights indeed tend to have the fewest delays and issues.

Disclosure: Some links on this page may be affiliate links. This means that I may earn a small commission if you decide to buy (at no additional cost to you).

 

U.S. Colonies Still Exist

Before fully jumping in, as a professional traveler, I think it’s important to point out Puerto Rico’s unique geopolitical position. Not that this is my area of expertise, but it is the elephant in the room. The island is a U.S. territory that uses the dollar and doesn’t require a passport for U.S. citizens, yet it maintains a rich, distinct culture that sets it apart. However, this relationship has many complexities. Despite being U.S. citizens, Puerto Ricans on the island can’t vote for president and lack representation in Congress. Correct me if I’m wrong, but most Puerto Ricans want sovereignty. It’s a situation reminiscent of other places like Hawaii.

Similar to many beautiful tourist destinations, Puerto Rico grapples with the double-edged sword of tourism. The economy has become dependent on the industry, and that presents many challenges. During my visit to Old San Juan, I witnessed massive cruise ships docking, flooding the streets with tourists who seemed unfamiliar with travel etiquette.

Another contentious issue is the influx of mainlanders taking advantage of tax incentives like Act 60, benefits unavailable to local residents. This is just one example of the ongoing economic and political challenges facing the island. These issues are complex and deeply rooted in history. As visitors, it’s crucial to be aware of this context. However, Puerto Rico’s incredible experiences deserve equal attention. With this understanding, let’s explore the beauty and culture this enchanting island has to offer.

 

The Capital City of Puerto Rico

For my initial Puerto Rico 5-day itinerary, I only stayed in San Juan. It’s the capital and largest city and stands among the oldest European-established cities in the Americas. However, the Taino people originally inhabited Puerto Rico, calling the island Boriken, which translates to “The land of the brave lord.

The historic district, Old San Juan, is a UNESCO World Heritage site and a port city. San Juan itself is a vibrant mix of old and new. Spanish might be the primary language, but many people speak English, especially in touristy areas. The local culture is a fascinating fusion of Spanish, African, and indigenous Taíno influences, reflected in the food, music, and festivals.

What’s the Best Piña Colada in San Juan?

The piña colada was invented in Puerto Rico, and Barrachina is often credited as its birthplace in the 1950s. However, I thought Raices was 10x better! Their version is thicker, which I prefer, and is reminiscent of the best one I’ve ever had in Curacao. I suspect their secret is a generous dose of coconut cream. Plus, it’s only $6 for a virgin piña colada and $8 with alcohol. What a steal! While Raices excels at drinks and has even hosted Anthony Bourdain, stick to their traditional Puerto Rican dishes rather than their attempts at other cuisines.

Where to Stay in San Jan, Puerto Rico

Don Rafa Boutique Hotel

I split my 5-day San Juan, Puerto Rico itinerary between two hotels for different vibes and experiences. First up is the Don Rafa Boutique Hotel & Residences. Situated in the historic district of Miramar, this is where urban living comes to life. Inspired by the 1950s ambiance, this hotel is where essence and nostalgia meet to elevate your experience through carefully curated details and personal attention.

While its aesthetic is stunning, it’s more about style than function. The cozy rooms suit solo travelers or couples well but offer limited storage space and compact bathrooms. I only stayed for one night, and since my travel companion was British, her accent was able to sweet-talk the front desk to upgrade us to a bigger room without charge. I have the worst luck, so on my own, that would’ve never happened! It’s also worth noting they have a photography policy, so I didn’t get much content.

Fairmont El San Juan

Next up is the hotel where I spent most of my time during my Puerto Rico 5-day itinerary after partnering with them to create content. Positioned on Isla Verde Beach, the Fairmont El San Juan Hotel is a beachfront property with a rich history, beautiful architecture, and easy access to Old San Juan. While the design and location are standout features, the hotel didn’t quite meet the high-end Fairmont expectations, in my opinion. If you’re curious about the full experience, check out my detailed hotel review here.

 

Unique Activity – Learn to Sail

If you’re following a 5-day San Juan, Puerto Rico itinerary, one standout experience I highly recommend is learning to sail. It’s a fantastic way to appreciate the island’s coastline and crystal-clear waters. This wasn’t something I was originally planning on doing, but said travel companion told me she always has to get on a boat when she travels, and I’m not one to turn down an adventure, so that’s what we did.

We booked a private boat, and it was fun because my friend knew how to sail, so the captain deemed it ok that we sail out into the Atlantic Ocean. So my first time ever sailing was out with some big swells! I ended up needing to steer longer than I anticipated because I started getting seasick, which had never happened to me before when I was out on the boat. The best way to combat that is to steer because it gives you something else to focus on, since seasickness is mostly mental.

A Place of Contrasts

Puerto Rico is a place of contrasts – a blend of familiar and foreign, of rich history and modern challenges. It’s a destination that invites you to look beyond the surface, to appreciate its beauty while also acknowledging its complexities. Puerto Rico is navigating a path between preserving its cultural heritage and adapting to tourism industry pressures. I hope this glimpse into my 5-day San Juan, Puerto Rico itinerary has inspired you to explore this unique corner of the Caribbean!

Frequently Asked Questions About Visiting San Juan, Puerto Rico

• Is San Juan safe for solo travelers?
  Yes, San Juan is generally safe, especially in tourist areas like Old San Juan and Condado. However, always practice standard safety precautions.
• How many days do you need in San Juan?
  5 days is a perfect amount of time to explore Old San Juan, enjoy the beaches, try local cuisine, and even take a day trip or sail.
• Do you need to speak Spanish in Puerto Rico?
  No, most people in tourist areas speak English. Knowing a few Spanish phrases can be helpful and appreciated.

Watch on YouTube

To keep up to date with everything I share, follow along on my social media and read up on what camera gear I use when I travel.

• Instagram
• TikTok
• YouTube
• Pinterest
• Facebook